A sheet of paper with seven purple dots beside seven blank lines lies on a wooden desk, with a child's crayon drawing of a house, a teddy bear, a small backpack, wellies, a lunchbox and a pair of glasses around it

Explainer · 7 min read

What does a judge look for in family court? The welfare checklist, in plain English

In a children case in England and Wales, the court's focus is the child's welfare. What the welfare checklist asks the court to weigh, the principles behind it, and how to prepare information the court can use.

Illustration: familycourt.app

It is natural to want to know what the judge is looking for. You may have heard that it comes down to who makes the best impression, or who has the better lawyer. In children cases in England and Wales, the law points the court somewhere else entirely: at your child. This guide explains what the court is asked to weigh, in plain English, so you can prepare information that is genuinely useful to it.

The short version

  • The child's welfare is the court's paramount consideration. That is the starting point in section 1 of the Children Act 1989.
  • The court works through a welfare checklist of seven factors, including the child's wishes and feelings, their needs, the effect of any change, and any risk of harm.
  • Delay is treated as harmful to children, so the court tries to avoid it.
  • The court only makes an order if that is better for the child than making none.
  • Cases can be heard by a judge, or by magistrates with a legal adviser. The same law applies either way.
  • What helps the court is clear, factual, child-focused information, not criticism of the other parent.

The starting point: the child's welfare comes first

When a court decides a question about a child's upbringing, such as where they live or how much time they spend with each parent, the law says the child's welfare must be its paramount consideration. It comes before what either parent wants, and before what feels fair between the adults.

Two other principles sit alongside it. Delay in deciding is likely to be harmful to the child. And the court should only make an order if doing so would be better for the child than making no order at all.

At the time of writing, the law also asks the court to presume that a child benefits from the involvement of both parents, unless that would put the child at risk. The government plans to remove that presumption through the Courts and Tribunals Bill, which has not yet become law. Our 2027 guide explains where that stands.

The welfare checklist

Where a children application is opposed, the court must consider a set of factors known as the welfare checklist. In plain English, they are:

  1. The child's wishes and feelings, understood in the light of their age and understanding. An older child's views usually carry more weight than a very young child's, but they are one factor, not the deciding vote.
  2. The child's needs: physical, emotional and educational.
  3. The likely effect of any change in the child's circumstances, such as a move of home or school.
  4. The child's age, sex, background and any characteristics the court considers relevant.
  5. Any harm the child has suffered or is at risk of suffering.
  6. How capable each parent is of meeting the child's needs, and any other person the court considers relevant.
  7. The range of orders available to the court.

The court weighs these together. No single factor automatically outweighs the others, and how much each matters depends on the child and the family.

Where safety is a concern

Where there are allegations of domestic abuse or other harm, the court follows a set of rules, known as Practice Direction 12J, about how to identify and deal with those concerns, and how any risk affects arrangements for the child. If this applies to you, our guide to Cafcass and its reports explains the safety checks that happen early in a case. If you are ever in immediate danger, call 999.

What helps the court

The court can only weigh what it is told, so it helps to prepare information that speaks to the checklist. This is about being organised and honest, not about performing.

  • Keep the focus on your child: their routine, needs, health, school and how they are coping
  • Be specific and factual: dates, events and what happened, rather than general feelings
  • Explain your proposals and how they would work in practice for your child
  • Describe the other parent neutrally and acknowledge what works well where you can
  • Follow court orders and meet every deadline
  • Be honest about difficulties, including your own
  • Raise any safety concerns clearly, with any evidence you have

A short (a brief document setting out your view and proposals for a hearing) and a clear chronology help the court find what it needs quickly. Our guide to writing a chronology shows how.

How the court hears from your child

Children rarely attend court. Their wishes and feelings usually reach the court through (the Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service), which may speak to them and report to the court. In areas running the Child Focused Model, this often happens earlier, in a Child Impact Report prepared before the first main hearing.

Common questions

What does a judge look for in family court?

In children cases, the court's focus is the child's welfare. It considers the welfare checklist in the Children Act 1989, including the child's wishes and feelings, their needs, the effect of any change, any risk of harm, and how able each parent is to meet the child's needs.

What is the welfare checklist?

It is a list of seven factors in section 1(3) of the Children Act 1989 that the court must consider when a children application is opposed. It helps the court decide what arrangements are in the child's best interests.

Does the child get to choose who they live with?

No. The child's wishes and feelings are an important factor, especially as they get older, but the court weighs them alongside everything else on the welfare checklist. The decision is the court's.

Does it matter if I don't have a lawyer?

Many parents represent themselves in family court. The court applies the same law either way, and the judge or legal adviser will usually explain the process. Being organised and child-focused helps whether or not you have a lawyer.

Sources

How familycourt.app and McKenzie can help

McKenzie, the app's AI assistant, explains each factor on the welfare checklist and how it relates to the facts of your own case, without telling you what to do or predicting the outcome. Document Studio helps you prepare your own position statement and chronology, child-focused and in the format the court expects, so the information the court weighs is clear and easy to find.

This is information to help you prepare and understand the process. It isn't legal advice. familycourt.app covers family court in England and Wales. If you are in immediate danger, call 999.

Read next

Keep going

All posts

Information, not legal advice. England and Wales.

Exit this page quickly. You can also press the Shift key three times.